This post contains affiliate links. Click here to read my affiliate policy.
Last Updated on April 30, 2025
You won’t stop after one spoonful of this luscious apple pie ice cream. Packed with warm cinnamon, nutmeg, and apples, this dairy-free ice cream is the real deal!
I’ve been putting my Cuisinart Ice Cream maker to use and thinking of fun ice cream recipes to make. My BFF was in town and I was running ideas past her on what sounded tempting and her eyes lit up when I said Apple Pie Ice Cream.
I knew I had to give it a whirl and I’m torn between being happy about another tasty recipe and the fact that I can’t just eat the whole dang container.
I know, these problems are pretty minor when compared to some, but I’m suffering over here.
If you want a nice crunchy add-on to the recipe, sprinkle on some of my Cinnamon Square Crunch Cereal Recipe. OMG, It’s freaking amazing with this recipe and gives it the “crust” to complete the recipe. The Little attacked this like he was trying out for a food competition so I figured it was a winner.
Apple Pie Ice Cream
What's better than a hot slice of apple pie? How about eating that delicious flavor in creamy, delicious form? This apple pie ice cream is the perfect treat. Get ready to indulge!
Ingredients
Apple Filing
- 1 Medium Tart Apple diced
- 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie seasoning or cinnamon
- 2 tablespoons ghee or coconut oil
- 1 tablespoon dark Maple Syrup
- 3 tablespoon water
- pinch of sea salt
Ice Cream
- 2 13.5 oz cans of full fat coconut milk
- 1/4 cup B grade maple syrup
- 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 1/2 teaspoon pumpkin pie seasoning or cinnamon
Instructions
- In a sauce pan place the diced apple, water, maple syrup, pumpkin pie spice and ghee.
- Cook on low until the water is evaporated and the apples are soft (not mushy), roughly 8 minutes.
- In a blender combine the coconut milk, vanilla, pumpkin pie spice and vanilla.
- Blend until well mixed.
- Now add in the apple filling and place the liquid in your ice cream maker for 15 minutes. Enjoy!
© 2011-2013, A Girl Worth Saving. Feel free to pin my posts but do not repost my full recipe on your blog, Tumblr, or any other website.
I’m thinking hard about trying the Paleo diet. I just don’t know if I can give up grains…. I love bread. And, Kelly, can you eat air-popped popcorn on a Paleo diet? Because that would definitely be a deal breaker for me. 🙂
Corn is grain so it’s on the do not eat list. HOWEVER, I doubt you can find one guru/blogger on the diet who doesn’t cheat including myself. If you can stick to a grain-free diet 90% of the time, you’ll see a huge difference in your health. If that means having popcorn every now and then for you to stay on the diet, I don’t see a problem with it.
Okay, that’s good to know. I would really have to have my air-popped popcorn at least once a week. If I knew I could reward myself with that, I might be able to do it. I’m still doing research and trying to get my husband on board. 🙂
Good luck if you try it and please feel free to email if you have more questions 🙂
ZOMG this sounds so good. Pinned for later!
Aw, thanks Meghan 🙂
I cant wait to try this!
Holy amazing, I need to taste that. You have a winner here. Apple pie IN ice cream. Perfect!
You scream, I scream….you know the rest LOL. Looks and sounds great. I’ve never tried an apple pie flavor but since I love ice cream on my apple pie I figure it has got to be good.
I NEED to buy myself an icecream maker…..
You won’t regret it! Check Marshall’s – they have some one sale right now.
Holy hell this looks amazing. I have an ice cream maker. I need this. lol. And I need to get to Whole Foods for ingredients.
This is my kind of ice cream! I love that you make it with coconut milk.
Oh that does sound delish! How about peaches – make me a peach ice cream recipe!
Tammy, I love the way you think!
Yum, this looks great. Love the mix of flavors.
Apple pie and vanilla ice cream! I love that your recipe calls for tart apples. I bet it would be great with a little caramel drizzled over it.
You can make ANYONE turn to a Paleo diet!
Oh man this looks so good! I love apples.
This, I need to make this! And can I come live with you lol I swear I wipe drool off my chin every time I visit your recipes.
Aw, that’s so sweet of you to say Jenn 🙂 I’m always up to company that will eat the desserts I make, lol. Less calories for me 🙂
YUMMY! You make paleo look so tasty.
Heaven in an ice cream and all clean ingredients. You rock Kelly!!
I’m actually going to try the base of this !!! M has to trial coconut and I can’t see a better recipe to try 🙂
Oh, how scrumptious! 🙂
That looks awesome! I love apple pie & ice cream, especially together, so I totally have to try this.
Apple pie ice cream, really? It sounds delicious!!
That looks great! I have been pondering using coconut milk as the base for ice cream. Thanks for sharing your recipe.
This looks so amazing! I love how you put pumpkin pie spice in it!
Oh. My. YUM!!!!!! All of those ingredients sound amazing!!
That looks mmm, mmm good!
I just had apple pie the other day and this sounds divine!
Seriously? What are you trying to do to me lady? This looks so dang good!
This looked amazing and easy but it was a total flop for us. Made exactly according to the recipe, and after 15 mins in our ice cream maker it was still liquid. 2 hours of freezer time later and it’s still not ice cream. Also can’t really taste the apple pie, mostly just coconut-ty! Not sure what we did wrong… 🙁
Did you use full fat coconut milk? That seems strange that it’s still not frozen after that long.
I preordered your cook book on amazon is it available Nov 2014? I can’t find it again HELP new to paelo diet but your r recipes are great love the notes
Hi Carol, the release date has been moved back to January 6th. Here’s the link again – http://amzn.to/1Dh9YOi. I will still be sharing a Thanksgiving Meal Plan this week!
I love your recipes, but sadly for us in Australia, we don’t have many of the ingredients that you use, eg. Pumpkin Pie spice. What would be a substitute for this?
Thanks
I would just use cinnamon hun 🙂